kaguya logoKaguya
  • Home
  • My Library
  • Browse
  • Lists
  • Members
  • Discussions
Log inSign up
kaguya logoKaguya
Sign up
Home
Browse
Library
Notifications
Notifications
Profile
About
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Guidelines
  • Help & Support
Contribute
  • Add Book
  • Add Covers
  • Librarian Guide
Apps
AndroidiOS

© 2025 Kaguya

Soul Eater

Review by greenishio

1/2
Aug 1(edited)
Soul Eater
Lily Mayne

I listened to Soul Eater by Lily Mayne and did not enjoy it. Mostly because I didn’t like Danny. He felt almost like a reader-insert character to me; his thoughts, feelings and action never quite build into a coherent character. (And why is he so frustratingly useless in all the dangerous situations?!) Also, the villains are annoyingly over the top evil. Wyn is fine but a little too nice for my liking.

The story really drags in places. The narrator uses a weird flat tone (I think he was aiming for a southern accent?) but it made Danny sound bored (or dead inside) even in emotional situations. His voice for Wyn is pretty cool though.

greenishio
Soul Eater
Lily Mayne
1/2
•Aug 1(edited)
Soul Eater

I listened to Soul Eater by Lily Mayne and did not enjoy it. Mostly because I didn’t like Danny. He felt almost like a reader-insert character to me; his thoughts, feelings and action never quite build into a coherent character. (And why is he so frustratingly useless in all the dangerous situations?!) Also, the villains are annoyingly over the top evil. Wyn is fine but a little too nice for my liking.

The story really drags in places. The narrator uses a weird flat tone (I think he was aiming for a southern accent?) but it made Danny sound bored (or dead inside) even in emotional situations. His voice for Wyn is pretty cool though.

Comments ()

More Reviews by greenishio
Bloodraven
Lost and Bound
The Alpha's Gamble
More Reviews bygreenishio
Bloodraven
Lost and Bound
The Alpha's Gamble
Sorcery and Small Magics
Brim Over Boot
Dove•Aug 1

Do you think you'll continue the series?

greenishio•Aug 2

@Dove I’m torn on this lol. Maybe later when I get kindle unlimited.  Are the human MCs more interesting in the later books?

Dove•Aug 2

@greenishio I think so - the MC in the next one is pretty grumpy, for example. I think the author does a pretty good job of making each book have a different dynamic between the MCs. But if you didn't enjoy the first one I don't know if you'll enjoy the rest tbh!

greenishio•Aug 2

@Dove Good to know, thanks!